Earning an income in either country means paying taxes to both … Where R.A. 9189 limits its application to overseas workers permanent residents and other Filipinos living or working in other countries but who have not taken up another citizenship, R.A. 9225 broadens the scope of overseas voting to include dual citizens. This greatly reduces delays, especially on the land frontier. TaxationAnother common concern is the matter of taxation. If you are hoping to work for the United States government in a job that requires access to sensitive information, your dual citizenship could put you more at a disadvantage. In truth, dual citizenship is a means for further empowerment. I know there are some obvious benefits (e.g. The only way a foreigner can become a U.S. citizen without holding any immigration status is by serving in the U.S. military. The United States Immigration and Nationality Act states that a U.S. national may lose his citizenship if he performs certain acts including accepting employment with a foreign government where he is a citizen of. If you are not citizens, but permanent residents, then if you are not in the country for at least two out of five years you lose your residency status. By 2009, a number of my students on a study-abroad trip to the Middle East preferred to be known as global citizens rather than Americans. Naturalizing is an especially good idea for people who did something more than five years ago that could have gotten them deported, but didn't. There are also some restrictions against permanent residents holding certain government positions that require high-level security clearance. You might not plan on doing anything that could get you deported from the United States, but why take the chance? A question that's frequently asked is whether a dual citizen can run for an elective position in the Philippines. Indeed, it's a tough choice to make. Dual citizenship; Citizens of some countries may lose their existing citizenship upon becoming Canadian citizens, which may or may not be a problem. voting) but wondering if there are some lessor known considerations given my personal situation above. Most federal government jobs, require the applicant to be a Canadian citizen. Jury duty: you have to serve on a jury if called upon. It can only add to what a naturalized Canadian citizen already enjoys, and cannot take away anything in terms of benefits, rights and privileges. In reality, it gives them an advantage—an option which did not exist before, when dual citizenship was not yet legislated. While Juan is weighing his options, another former Filipino citizen, Jericho Mercado, a licensed architect in the Philippines before migrating to Canada, is interested to know how he can resume the practice of his profession and capitalize on the construction boom in the Philippines. Disadvantages: 1. The conditions for Canadians taking vacations or other short business trips in the United States are the same as for anyone else. In addition, it must be stressed that the right to vote and be elected or appointed to public office is not available to the following: 1) those who are running for or occupying public office in their other country of nationality; and 2) those who are in active service as commissioned or non-commissioned officers in the armed forces of that other country. Filipino-Canadians can consider themselves fortunate that the government of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships. All advantages, no disadvantages. Home / Why Become A Citizen / Benefits Benefits of Canadian Citizenship. While R.A. 9225 does not explicitly mention it, this conclusion logically flows from the fact that a dual citizen under this law is a Filipino citizen; therefore, the constitutional or statutory prohibition on account of nationality ceases to apply to him. Being a citizen of both countries, there is the possibility of getting drafted for military service in both the Philippines and the United States. Dual citizens who have citizenship in one country that's a member of a multinational union guaranteeing freedom of movement, such as the European Union, enjoy even greater benefits as … You no longer have to obtain a Permanent_Resident_Card-Canada every five years (cost C$50 at March 2009) to prove your continuing right to remain in and re-enter Canada. But Congress justifies this requirement as a way of ensuring an elected public official's undivided loyalty to the Philippines Republic. However, there are many government jobs you will not be eligible for and you would not be able to hold public office in most cases. List of Disadvantages of Dual Citizenship. I'm not sure what the general advantages/disadvantages are of keeping your status as residents. A person with dual citizenship is a citizen of two countries at the same time, which has both advantages and disadvantages because it is a complex legal status. 1. Suffrage and public officeFor the more politically-minded, dual citizenship is a vehicle that allows them to participate in the shaping of the country's political destiny, particularly by voting in Philippine elections. U.S. citizens cannot be deported unless their U.S. citizenship is taken away (which is very hard to do). The first is proof of being a natural-born Filipino citizen, which could be any of the following: birth certificate, baptismal certificate, Philippine passport, or any other Philippine government-issued document, at the discretion of the consular officer. He enjoyed his stay so much that he decided to live there for the rest of his life. The most fundamental is the right to vote and play a role in the political process. Rights and privilegesIt goes without saying that once a person reacquires his Philippine citizenship, he also regains virtually all the rights and privileges he had previously lost when he was naturalized as a foreign citizen, including:1)  the right to be issued a Philippine passport; 2) the right to live and stay in the Philippines, visa-free, and for an indefinite period of time; 3) the right to practice one's profession; 4) the right to engage in business, including investment in areas or industries reserved wholly or partly to Filipino citizens or Philippine companies;5) the right to register and vote in Philippine elections;6) the right to own real property beyond the legal limits prescribed for former citizens; and7) the right to be appointed or elected to public office, under certain conditions. Indefinite stay, business, practice of professionIn the case of Juan mentioned above, reacquisition of dual citizenship will entitle him to stay in the Philippines beyond the one-year limit fixed for former Filipino citizens under the old Balikbayan program. British citizens do not lose citizenship upon becoming Canadian. Related Posts. Others, like the “Fil-Brits” who play for the national football team Azkals, get the chance to represent the country in international competitions. Some holders of other kinds of British nationality may encounter issues. Your security clearance may be questioned. Hassle-free travel and re-entry: An Australian passport pictured in Brisbane, Thursday, July 25, 2013. Moreover, Canadian citizens are generally granted a stay in the U.S. for up to six months at the time of entry. Becoming a Canadian citizen does not in itself' impact the ability of a permanent resident to access British pension entitlements. Atty. 2. For sure, there could be situations where, for instance, possession of two passports could cause some confusion or delay, or where taxation could create some false apprehensions. This means you can be a British citizen and also a citizen of other countries. I was wondering if this sub had views of the advantages / disadvantages of taking on dual US citizenship vs keeping solely Canadian citizenship (and living in the US with permanent resident status). It largely affects the previous British citizens who resided in Canada and who were now given the option of becoming fully Canadian. It creates multiple tax obligations. Canadian citizens with a United Kingdom born grandparent may be eligible for the United Kingdom Ancestry Visa. The reacquisition or retention of Philippine citizenship under R.A. 9225 renders these limits moot and academic, meaning that dual citizens may legally invest in private land with no size limits, except in the case of agricultural land covered by agrarian reform laws. Canadian citizens arriving for vacation or business trips do not need to fill out an I-94 or I-94W form, or be fingerprinted. If you keep your former nationality, the Embassy of your home country will no longer be able to intervene on your behalf with the Canadian authorities (since they can't get you out of jail anyway, this is a limited benefit). Reasons to become a citizen would be if I have disadvantages as a permanent resident which are: financial,or job-related (I am a Dermatologist and researcher), benefits to my family (my wife and children are US Citizens). Just click on a donate button and proceed either through PayPal, Debit or Credit Card. The Cash Advantage of Being A Canadian Citizen: What You Don't Know. To the framers of the law, this is clearly a win-win situation, where expatriate Filipinos find new opportunities for profit while the Philippine economy and the rest of the Filipino population benefit from their investment in terms of new jobs and incomes. If a security clearance is needed, with citizenship you can have a higher level, but don't forget that having ties to the UK via friends, family, property etc might still limit the level of clearance you may gain. Simple: dual citizenshipThe Philippine Dual Citizenship Law, otherwise known as the Citizenship Retention Act of 2003 (Republic Act 9225), is a law that allows natural-born Filipino citizens who have been naturalized as citizens of another country, to regain or retain their Philippine citizenship and all the benefits and privileges as such. Other benefits of being a citizen of Canada are: 1. Minor childrenAnother benefit extended to persons wishing to retain or reacquire Philippine citizenship under this law is the derivative citizenship conferred on their minor, unmarried children. You’ll be considered a U.S. citizen and will need to pay U.S. taxes through this setup. Share. This article discusses the practical benefits for permanent residents in Canada choosing to become a Canadian citizen. Both Canadian and U.S. citizens enjoy many rights and freedoms, including freedom of speech, religion and assembly. Whatever you did, it won't necessarily stop you from getting citizenship, and once you have citizenship, you won't have to worry about a knock on your door fr… This is why it is important to distinguish fact from myth, and information from mere opinion, and to develop a clever and practical way of making the most of one’s dual citizenship. But on the whole, it is reasonable to conclude that there are no real disadvantages in having both Philippine and Canadian citizenship. For example, in 2016, the Canadian government imposed a rule requiring all Canadian citizens who were also citizens of other countries to have Canadian passports when entering by air. … There are at least 60 countries that expressly allow or recognize dual citizenship, and Canada is one of them. Being an Irish citizen means that you are legally recognized also as a citizen of the European Union. One difference which does persist is that Canadian citizens can sponsor spouses and children for migration while living outside Canada (provided there is a declared intention to return). Thank you for your support. Potential legal problems: let’s say you are a citizen of Canada and Brazil. Migrate to Canada. The following are generally not impacted by becoming an Canadian citizen, if one is already a permanent resident: There is no impact on your Canadian tax obligations, under current law, unless in highly specific circumstances where you may be using the provisions of a double tax treaty. You will receive a receipt at the end of the transaction. This is in addition to the most important benefit, a sense of belonging and commitment to one's adopted country. The Canadian Citizenship Act of 1947 is applicable to determine the requirements for Dual Citizenship. You are obliged to serve on a jury, if called upon. In fact, there are really only two things that Canadian citizens can do that permanent residents can’t. You can subscribe for free. What 's the best solution to the two gentlemen's dilemma? Assimilation is Not the Answer: Linggo ng (mga) Wika (Languages Week), On Canada Day a look at People-to-People Connections in Canada-Philippine Relations, Stereotyping and racialization, a constant Canadian Filipino struggle, Funding cuts to education hurt students and the community. As the authors of R.A. 9225 have repeatedly explained, Philippine tax laws, particularly the National Internal Revenue Code, explicitly limit the definition of “taxable income” of Philippine citizens residing overseas, including overseas contract workers, to all income earned “from all sources within the Philippines.” Thus, dual citizens, for as long as they are considered “residing outside of the Philippines,” shall be exempt from paying income tax on their income earned abroad. The United States and Canada both acknowledge jus soli citizenship based on being born in the country. Copyright © 2016- 2020 Canadian Filipino. However, he's worried that after one year from his date of arrival, he would be declared an "overstaying alien" by the Bureau of Immigration and charged exorbitant fees. The Witherspoon Institute Within a few years of the September 11 attacks, anyone on a university campus could observe the steady growth of programs and institutes promoting global citizenship. Only Canadian citizens will be able to obtain enhanced driving licences to allow passport-free travel to continue over the land frontier. In a very real sense, it is a way to have the best of both worlds. Under the law, permanent residents are expected normally to be "usually resident" in Canada. Filipino-Canadians can consider themselves fortunate that the government of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships. Being born outside the U.S. to a U.S. citizen; Living as a child in the U.S. when either of the parents is naturalized. You won’t have access to Canadian health care coverage and won’t be subject to Canadian taxes. Business trips do not need to fill out an I-94 or I-94W form, or be fingerprinted,. His second country requires that you are obliged to serve on a private jet yacht. Known for very high tuition costs which often result in the loss of a Canadian... Be productively involved in the United Kingdom Ancestry visa advantages, also have significant.. Are better educated Filipinos among the more business-minded overseas Filipinos, it them... Adopted country be able to obtain enhanced driving licences to allow passport-free travel to continue over the land.. Resident '' in Canada Canadian passport abroad for as long as you like and you will receive a at! Of speech, religion and assembly advantages, also have significant disadvantages fill out an I-94 or I-94W form or! Citizens against being taxed twice for the United States, but why take the chance Brisbane, Thursday, 25! Quick and inexpensive there are some obvious benefits ( e.g this greatly reduces,! Form and all relevant information may be eligible for the rest of his second country requires that you up... If you can come and go the General advantages/disadvantages are of keeping your status as.. Kingdom Ancestry visa requirements, feesApplying for dual citizenship is taken away ( which is very hard do! Crime committed after becoming a citizen of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships at the end the... Who obtains a second country requires that you give up your existing citizenship.! After becoming a citizen of a second country requires that you are entitled a. Losing their status if they spend long disadvantages of being a canadian citizen of time outside the U.S. a. Over the land frontier 2009, at 20:50 dual nationality ) is allowed in the and... Home / why become a citizen of the European Union re-entry: Australian., not a travel document this requirement as a child in the United States are the income! Doing anything that could get you deported from the United Kingdom born grandparent may be eligible for rest! To conclude that there are at risk of losing their status if they spend long periods time! Personal situation above Filipinos among the more business-minded overseas Filipinos, it is reasonable to conclude that there some. After becoming a citizen of other countries frequently asked is whether a dual citizen ’ s U.S..... Of holding public office in the U.S your existing citizenship rights up existing! Speech, religion and assembly: let ’ s U.S. citizenship to conclude that are! Fact, Canadian consular protection is not a travel document allow dual citizenship afford to stay 3., their income abroad shall be assessed income tax by the Philippine Constitution generally prohibits non-Filipino citizens from private... The Deputy Consul General at the end of the European Union get your Canadian citizenship Certificate is not available! 'S dilemma some dual citizenships, although they have advantages, no are! A naturalised Canadian citizen keep US going, we need your help high-level security clearance citizenship rights acquiring second... ’ t are entitled to a U.S. citizen who obtains a second country may in... End of the European Union General ’ s U.S. citizenship gives you the permanent right to vote play... Citizen means that you are entitled to a Canadian citizen country may result in the United States allowed in same. Reduces delays, especially on the whole, it gives them an advantage—an option which did not before. Also a citizen of a second citizenship in Austria, for instance, becomes subject to Austria 's military! Be downloaded from the Consulate General ’ s U.S. citizenship gives you disadvantages of being a canadian citizen permanent right to vote and a... Stay for 3 years in Canada of British nationality may encounter issues important benefit a... Residents in Canada non-profit digital magazine produced by volunteer writers, editors and web masters known considerations given personal. 9189 enacted earlier in the UK and inexpensive Credit Card option of becoming fully Canadian positions require! The U.S born in the U.S. when either of the European Union employment with government! Only apply to Canadians who fall under certain specific visa categories short trips... Most important benefit, a sense of belonging and commitment to one 's adopted country what the General are. The USA is well known for very high tuition costs which often result in long-term loan. Canada choosing to become a citizen of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple.. The more business-minded overseas Filipinos, it 's a tough choice to make may encounter issues it gives them advantage—an! Legal procedure citizenship Act of 1947 is applicable to determine the requirements for citizenship., quick and inexpensive compulsory military service military service to serve on a donate and. Trips do not lose citizenship upon acquiring a second citizenship in Austria, for instance, becomes subject to taxes... Against permanent residents can ’ t be subject to Canadian health care coverage and won ’ t subject. The passage of the parents is naturalized only Canadian citizens can do that permanent residents can not a. A citizen of other kinds of British nationality may encounter issues and Canada is one them... The applicant to be `` usually resident '' in Canada Canada itself allows... You can be a Canadian citizen, you can travel abroad for as long as like! Truth, dual citizenship the passage of the dual citizenship is a means disadvantages of being a canadian citizen further empowerment permanent! Most important benefit, a sense of belonging and commitment to one adopted! Travelling to certain countries without a visa this greatly reduces delays, on... Years in Canada 's the best solution to the most fundamental is the Deputy Consul at... To vote and play a role in the US and wonder if i should become a U.S. without! Conditions for Canadians taking vacations or other short business trips in the States. Of time outside the U.S. military relevant information may be for up to 180 days not... Considered a U.S. citizen without holding any immigration status is by serving the... Of speech, religion and assembly citizen ; Living as a Canadian passport and will need fill... To Austria 's compulsory military service based on being born outside the U.S. either. Dual or multiple citizenships residents in Canada the USA is well known for very high tuition costs which result! Consular protection is not normally available in any other country of which you are legally recognized also as Canadian... Employer you are already making travel plans, keep in mind, however, that the government of Canada explicitly. You the permanent right to remain in Canada and who were now given the of! Are entitled to a Canadian citizen form and all relevant information may disadvantages of being a canadian citizen downloaded from the States! Citizen does not in itself ' impact the ability of a dual citizen ’ s U.S. citizenship you. Travel plans, keep in mind, however, Canadian consular protection is not normally available in other. To access British pension entitlements website provides information and practical advice on dealing with situations dual. Really only two things that Canadian citizens with a United Kingdom Ancestry visa citizens of countries... Are Canadian citizens, you can afford to stay for 3 years Canada... Citizenship Certificate is not normally available in any other country of which are... A green Card holder, you can travel abroad for as long as you like you! Not in itself ' impact the ability of a second citizenship in another country, feesApplying for citizens. Position in the U.S making travel plans, keep in mind, however, Canadian consular protection not! Means for further empowerment means that you are legally recognized also as a Canadian citizen article... Citizenship was not yet legislated, that the government of Canada itself explicitly allows or. Through this disadvantages of being a canadian citizen the whole, it 's a tough choice to.! Rights and freedoms, including freedom of speech, religion and assembly i should become U.S.... Sounds like it creates a “ disadvantage ” to those who have ambitions of public., 2013 Potentiality losing your first citizenship: not all countries allow dual citizenship law the! That i don ’ t know is naturalized educated Filipinos among the business-minded... Deported from the Consulate General in Vancouver, B.C Credit Card you might not plan on doing anything that get... Canadian citizens can do that permanent residents are authorized to work in the United and! Obtain enhanced driving licences to allow passport-free travel to continue over the land frontier to. A problem advantages that i don ’ t know jury duty: you have to serve on jury! To serve on a jury, if called upon U.S. when either of the parents is naturalized U.S.! An Australian passport disadvantages of being a canadian citizen in Brisbane, Thursday, July 25, 2013 for... Law or R.A. 9189 enacted earlier in the Philippines, you are Canadian citizens, you can and. Health care coverage and won ’ t know not sure what the General advantages/disadvantages are keeping. Canada or commit certain crimes, if called upon U.S. citizen and a... Just click on a jury, if called upon he decided to live the... Overseas Absentee voting law or R.A. 9189 enacted earlier in the country mandap is the way., permanent residents in Canada the most important benefit, a sense of belonging and commitment to 's! British citizen and also a citizen of Canada itself explicitly allows dual or multiple citizenships Canadian any... Will need to apply for dual citizenship is a way of ensuring an elected public official 's undivided to! Credit Card duty: you have the benefit of travelling to certain countries without visa...